XPday London

Say no to the Cargo Cult

 

Submitter: Francisco Trindade & Luca Grulla

 

The Agile Manifesto has been signed in 2001, and since then agile practices have gone from being used in niches to become mainstream and widely adopted.

After this time, we would expect teams to move in the Dreyfus model, progressing from novice to expert levels, understanding the values and questioning the current practices. Instead, the evolution in Agile practices is presented as off-the-shelf solutions and ready to use jargon, making most agile teams stay put, changing from being novice in one set of practices to being novice in every new set which is proposed by the industry, without never really getting into its core values, and losing the focus on the main goal, which is to deliver software.

This presentation is going to question the way Agile practices are presented and adopted, and how the search for quick pre-made solutions can impact negatively the future of the movement.

 


Process

We will introduce our point of view in a 45 minutes presentation, with the first half focused on how Agile has been adopted and the second half focused on our point of view on how the current approach can negatively impact the agile movement in the future.

During the first half of the presentation we will use example of agile practices related to the Dreyfus model to start a conversation with the audience, identifying real world example of "novice-to-novice" transition.

These will give the base for introducing in the second half of the session what we believe are the problems on how Agile has been adopted in the industry, and will let us close the session facilitating a discussion amongst the audience members, comparing our point of view with the ones coming from the audience.

 

Learning outcomes

 


    * Change the way you see agile adoption
    * Question the way agile is being adopted/sold
    * Understand why you are struggling doing agile

This presentation will also be conducted at the Agiles 2009 conference in Brazil (http://www.agiles2009.org/en/session.php?id=5)

 

 

Comments

From Luca Grulla [81.136.149.240] - 2009-09-29

We expanded the process description in order to increase the interaction with the audience and, following the feedback, we put a more provocative title as well.

New feedback are obviously welcome !

Luca

From Francisco Trindade [94.193.96.179] - 2009-09-10

I believe its more than a lightning talk because we expect participants to have opinions about it. The message we want to pass is exactly that you can't buy (or sell) agile-in-a-box, and we intend to allow opinions and discussions during the session.

Maybe that wasn't clear in the proposal, so we will update it.

Thanks for your comments,

Francisco

From Antony Marcano and Andy Palmer [86.16.245.96] - 2009-09-09

Our experience is also that many companies these days seem to want "Agile in a box" without really understanding why they would want to be doing it. A side effect of mainstream status?

A more provocative title might be good... and perhaps run this as a facilitated discussion with some key points providing a transition between sections of the discussion.

Your average xp-day alumni would probably have many opinions to share, and your newbies would learn a lot by hearing the stories people have to tell about why you can't buy agile-in-a-box.

Too big a subject for a lightening talk, could be a good 45min session either in the programme or as an open space.

From Rachel Davies [212.84.97.237] - 2009-09-03

Agree with Steve Freeman, this could be an Open Space session or a Lightning Talk.

From SteveFreeman [208.51.118.2] - 2009-08-28

Is this more than an open space session?

Page

New
Edit
Rename
Versions

Menu

Edit Menu
Versions

Site

Changes
Index
Search
Templates

User

Log In

 
 

Last Modified 2009-09-29